COURT CASES OF AIR & DOORDARSHAN
Diploma Holders after 10 yrs Service:
WP(C) No. 2671/2017 before Delhi High Court is next listed on
Order of High Court passed on
Modifications in Policy of MACP Scheme, 2009:
Various courts have modified
the policy of MACP scheme, 2009 which was originally notified by
DOP&T. Though, these modifications have been implemented in case of
the Petitioners, they are not generalised by the DOP&T for all the
Central Govt departments as on date. These modifications are:
(1) MACP is admissible in Promotional hierarchy of posts
Judgment of Pb & Hary High
Court in case of Raj Pal (b)
Judgment of Supreme Court in
case of Raj Pal.
(2) MACP is admissible ignoring Promotions availed by Departmental
Judgment of Madras
High Court in case of D. Sivakumar
Judgment of Supreme
Court in case of D. Sivakumar
(3) MACP being part of pay is admissible from 01.01.2006
(a) Judgment of Supreme Court in
case of Balbir Singh Turn (b)
Judgment of Delhi High Court in
case of Sunil Kumar Tyagi
(4) MACP is admissible ignoring NFU from GP-4800 to GP-5400 after 4
Judgment of Delhi High Court in case of Hari Ram
3rd MACP in
3rd MACP in
GP-6600 to Superintendents of Central Excise (MF, DoR) was DENIED by
CAT, Ernakulam. NFU granted in GP-5400 (PB-2) after 4 yrs of service
in GP-4800 was offset against one MACP out of total three.
Order dtd 12.04.2019 of CAT,
Ernakulam in OA No.916/2016 filed by Dileep Kumar.
Retired on 30th June
for grant of one increment on 01st July with all consequential
benefits including Pensionary benefits. (1)
15.09.2017 of Madras High Court in WP(C) No.15732/2017
(2) Judgment dated
23.07.2018 of Supreme Court in SLP No.22008/2018
(3) Judgment dated
08.08.2019 of Supreme Court in Review Petition No.1731/2019.
Merger of EA &
SEA wef 01.01.2006:
Next date of
hearing in Delhi high Court in WP(C) No.
8712/2018 titled UOI vs Vijay R Haror is 30.01.2020.
(1) Click here for the Order of HC.
(2) Order of CAT, Delhi dated
ACP in Rs 8000-13500:
WP No. 10786/2017 (CRN No. HCMA011699832017)
filed by Mrs Sasikala Selvaraju before Madras High Court for grant
of ACP benefits is listed for hearing on 18.10.2019.
Stopping Refixation & Recovery: MIB & CCA(MIB)
issued clarifications dated
26.09.2019 on maintaining status quo in Recovery & Refixation
of pay of subordinate engg. employees, consequent upon Stay Order
passed by Delhi High Court in WP(C) No. 9890/2019 filed by AADEE.
(1). Order of Ministry of I&B.
(2) Order of CCA(MIB) ,
Stay order dated
13.09.2019 passed by Delhi High Court.
here for the Order of DGAIR
Merger of EA &
SEA wef 01.01.2006: Contemt Petition No. 310/2018
in OA No. 282/2018 inVijay Haror case of merger
of EA & SEA cadres came up for hearing on 20.09.2019 before Delhi
CAT. Court has given last opportunity to govt to file reply, and
fixed next date of hearing on 22.11.2019.
Stopping Recovery & Refixation:
Delhi High Court, vide order
dated 13.09.2019 in WP(C) No.9890/2019 filed by AADEE, has granted
STAY on operation of judgment dated 01.08.2019 of CAT, Delhi passed
in OA No.2449/2018. Next date of hearing is scheduled for 23.01.2020.
Click here for High Court
2034/2017 (DGAIR vs Shyamali Biswas)
MACP in GP 5400 was listed for hearing on 18.07.2019. Govt has
requested for more time to file rejoinder in the case. Next date of
hearing is 03.11.2019.
Merger of Sr.Tech/Tech/Diesel
Tech/Mast Tech: Prasar Bharati
has recommended to MIB for merger of 4 cadres in the new post of
Junior Broadcast Engineer. See
Order dated 28.05.2019
Patna CAT has passed an Interim Order
on 17.05.2019 to DGAIR, in OA No. 283/2018 filed by B.K.Roy,
H.K.Mishra & Sudhanshu Kumar, to withdraw their order dated
13.05.2017 envisaging refixation of pay by withdrawing benefit of
ACP. DGAIR has issued order on 15.05.2019 in compliance of the
CAT's interim order. (1)
DGAIR's Order dated
Pay Fixation of Tech/Sr.Tech:
It seems wit is at large in
DGAIR when they issued one more ambiguous order dated 11.03.2019 in
the name of clarification to their order dated 07.02.2019. The DGAIR
did not say in the recent order as to which notional pay scales
shall be allowed wef 01.07.1983 and 01.01.1986 to Tech/Sr.Tech which
was once clarified by them vide order dated 11.03.2014. Click here
to view DGAIR's Orders (1) Order dated 11.03.2014 (2)
Order dated 07.02.2019
(3) Order dated 11.03.2019
OA No.2575/2018 filed by Yogesh Kumar & ARTEE
before CAT, Delhi (after dismissal of CP No. 715/2015 in OA
No.2479/2015 & WP(C) No.5168/2018 filed by ARTEE)
is scheduled for hearing on
06.08.2019. The case is for grant of stay on refixation/recovery
(on operation of MIB order dated 31.01.2018)
by withdrawing one MACP after treating pay scale of 25.02.1999 as
one "upgradation" equivalent to MACP.
Order dtd 01.12.17 in No.
Order dtd 01.12.2017 in CP
dtd 15.05.2018 in WP(C) No. 5168/2018
Stay granted on 13.07.2018 in OA
Interim Order dated 22.04.2019
in OA No. 2575/2018