Union of Akashvani & Doordarshan (Prasar Bharati) Engineering Employees (UADEE)
visit our website: http://www.uadee.org
ACP SCHEME , 1999 NOTIFIED ON 09.08.1999
BRIEF NOTE ON THE POLICY OF ACP SCHEME,
COURTS' ORDERS ON ADMISSIBILITY OF ACP SCHEME FOR EA, SEA & AE OF AIR &DD
The 5th Central Pay Commission had recommended for introduction of Assured Career Progression scheme (in short ACP scheme hereinafter) for the central Government civilian employees as a safety net to deal with the problems of genuine stagnation and hardship faced by the employees due to lack of adequate promotional avenues.
The Union Government had accepted to introduce the ACP scheme recommended by the Pay Commission and notified it vide Government of India, Department of Personnel &Training’s OM No. 35034/1/97-Estt.(D), dated 09.08.1999 (click to read PDF file of the order). As per the broad guide-lines of the scheme, the employees of Group B, C and D have been allowed maximum 2 financial up-gradations to the next higher grades in the existing or analogous hierarchy of posts after 12 and 24 years of regular service in the grade (to be counted from the date of direct entry in Govt. service) if no regular promotions during the prescribed periods have been availed by them.
The Government had also issued a set of 32 clarifications vide DOP&T’s O.M. No. 35034/1/97- Estt. (D) (Vol. IV), dated 10.02.2000 (click to read PDF file of the order) on points raised by various Ministries/Departments pertaining to implementation of the ACP scheme wherein, at Sr.No.1, it has clarified that an employee who got promoted from lower pay scale to higher pay scale as a result of promotion prior to 01.01.1996 and the pay scales of his feeder and promoted posts have been merged by the 5th Pay Commission during the rationalization of structure of new pay scales effective from 01.01.1996, he shall be entitled for upgradation to the next higher scale in the hierarchy under the ACP scheme ignoring the said promotion.The subordinate engineering employees of AIR & DD were denied the benefits of the ACP Scheme by Ministry of I&B and DOP&T on the grounds that they have already availed upgradation of their pay scales by Ministry of I&B's order dated 25.02.1999 (click to read PDF file of the order).
The direct recruit diploma holder EA, SEA, & AE of AIR &DD formed a forum named 'Akashvani & Doordarshan Diploma Engineers Association' and filed an OA No. 514 of 2002 before Patna Bench of CAT, lead by its President Sh. B.K.Roy, SEA and 11 other members of the Association working at AIR/DDK Patna, for grant of benefits of the ACP Scheme under Clarification No. 19 & 32 of the clarifications dated 10.02.2000 of DOP&T in the analogous hierarchy of CCW of AIR & DD. The OA was allowed vide order dated 07.09.2009 with direction to the Govt. to grant 1st Financial Upgradation in the pay scale of Rs 8000-275-13500 corresponding to pay scale of Assistant Executive Engineer of CCW of AIR &DD by ignoring all previous promotions from EA to SEA and thereafter from SEA to AE since all the pre-revised lower and higher pay scales of Rs 2000-3200, Rs 2000-3275 and Rs 2000-3500 held by the posts of EA, SEA and AE respectively had been merged to a single revised pay scale of Rs 6500-10500 by the 5th CPC wef 01.01.1996 (click to read PDF file of the order) .
The Govt. challenged the order dated 07.09.2009 passed in OA No. 514 of 2002 by CAT, Patna Bench by filing a C.W.J.C. No. 6451 of 2010 before Hon’ble Patna High Court. Hon’ble High Court had upheld the order of the Tribunal by order dated 25.08.2010 with the modification to the extent that the cases of the applicants be considered individually in accordance with the scheme of the ACP and the clarification contained in DOP&T’s order dated 10.02.2000 while granting them the pay scale of Rs 8000-275-13500 under the scheme of ACP.
Thereafter, the Union of India went to Supreme Court of India filing SLP No. CC 20212 of 2010 against the judgment dated 25.08.2010 passed by Hon,ble Patna High Court in C.W.J.C. No. 6451 of 2010 ( arising of order dated 07.09.2009 of CAT, Patna Bench in OA No. 514 of 2002). The SLP was dismissed on facts on 10.01.2011. Thus the case reached to the finality.
The Ministry of I&B took advice of DOP&T, Ministry of Finance and Ministry of Law on next course of action, which had advised to implement the order dated 07.09.2009 of CAT since no other option was left after the Govt's SLP was dismissed by Supreme Court and the case had attained finality. Ministry of I&B then decided and issued order dated 29.06.2011 (click to read PDF file of the order) for implemention of order dated 07.09.2009 in case of petitioners only. The Screening Committee of Ministry of I&B in which two members were Chief Engineers of AIR &DD have however decided and passed orders on 04.11 2011 to the petitioners saying that the ACP Scheme was not admissible to them and that no one was found eligible for grant of the benefit (click to read PDF file of the order). When informed to the CAT of this decision of the Screening Committee during the Contempt proceedings,
Hon’ble Tribunal held that the order dated 04.11.2011 of the respondents was not in consonance with the order of this Tribunal dated 07.09.2009 in OA No. 514/2002 as well as the order of High Court dated 25.08.2010 in C.W.J.C. No. 6451/2010 and the instructions of the DOP&T in the order dated 10.02.2000. Hon’ble CAT directed for the personal appearance of the CEO, Prasar Bharati to explain why charges for contempt should not be framed against him.The Screening Committee then hurriedly viewed its decision of 04.11.2011 and recommended to implement the order dated 07.09.2009 of CAT but in case of only 8 applicants by misinterpreting the judgment that it was passed in case of only 12 applicants of the OA and not for all the members of the association (click to read PDF file of the recommendations of the Screening Committee) . The DG:AIR issued order No. 8/3/2011-S-IV(B)pt.II, dated 17.01.2012 granting pay scale of Rs 8000-13500 to 8 applicants wef 01.01.2008 instead of actual dates had 12 years of service been counted from the dates of initial appointment in service (click to read PDF file of the order) .Four applicants including Sh. B. K. Roy were denied the benefits of the ACP Scheme on false and fictitious grounds that they did not ever draw in the pay scale of Rs 6500-10500. This was again a mischievous attempt to implement the ACP Scheme but in quite impaired manner which was brought to the notice of the Court by the the applicants in the contempt application.
The contempt petition CCPA 22 of 2011 filed before CAT, Patna Bench against non-implementation of order of the CAT in ACP case was disposed of by Hon'ble CAT by the order dated 23.05.2012 with the following observations and directions,
(a) That the Govt. has granted the benefit of ACP scheme to the petitioners quite erroneously by misinterpretation of judgment and going by the literal meaning of the words in para-9 of the order dated 07.09.2009 of the CAT.
(b) That any dispute on the methods of implementation of court's order is not under the purview in a contempt proceedings and that, if any, can be decided through a fresh OA if filed by the petitioners.
(c) That the petitioners may represent to the Govt. afresh for grant of the benefits of the ACP as per the provisions of the scheme and various clarifications issued by DOP&T in the matter and the direction set out in the order dated 07.09.2009 of CAT and the order dated 25.08.2010 of High Court.
(d) That if any representation is filed by the petitioners, the Govt. should go by the letter and spirit of the entire order of CAT as well as the order of Patna High Court, instead of being circumscribed limited by para-9 of the order of CAT.
(e) That the petitioners may prefer filing of a fresh OA before the Tribunal for correct implementation of ACP scheme.
Though the Govt. has implemented the order dated 07.09.2009 of CAT in correct way and in accordance with the rules of ACP Scheme in case of one of the applicants Sh. B. K. Roy, SEA of AIR, CBS, Patna now (click to read PDF file of the fixation order), it implemented the ACP Scheme erroneously in case of 8 other applicants in OA No. 512/2002 and it has not implemented at all in case of rest 3 applicants of OA No. 512/2002 till now. Three petitioners ( Sh. H. K. Mishra, Shri Sudhanshu Kumar & Sh. Manoramjan Kumar) of the main OA No. 514/2002 who were granted pay scale of Rs 8000.275-13500 wrongly wef 01.01.2008 as 1st upgradation under ACPS (click to read PDF file of the fixation order), had filed OA No. 350/2013 before CAT, Patna for implementation of ACP Scheme to them in correct way in accordance with the rules and as per the direction dated 23.05.2013 of CAT, Patna Bench passed in contempt application No. 22/2012. The OA has been decided on 31.01.2014 in favour the petitioners.
Although, the decision dated 07.09.2009 passed by CAT, Patna Bench had attained finality after Govt. was defeated in Patna High Court and Supreme Court and also, the nodal ministries of Union of India ( DOP&T, Ministry of Expenditure and Ministry of Legal Affairs) had vetted the case and advised to the Ministry of I&B to implement the Court's order being no other option than to implement the judgment, nevertheless the Ministry of I&B had filed a Review Petition (Civil) No. 141/ 2012 before Patna High Court to quash original order dated 07.09.2009 of the Patna CAT and to review its own earlier decision dated 25.08.2010 in CWJC 6451/2010 in the ACP case. Govt's this action was only to trifle with the issue and delay the implementation of ACP scheme to others, because the case had already attained finality from the Supreme Court of India. The Review Petition came for hearing on 23.10.2013. Hon'ble High Court opined that the Review Petition, having no merit, needed to be dismissed. On this, the Government's counsel prayed that he may be permitted to withdraw the Review Petition which was allowed by the court (click to read PDF file of the High Court order). Now, there is no case pending in any of courts challenging the order dated 07.09.2009 of CAT, Patna Bench. The Govt. has to grant now the benefit of ACP Scheme to all the eligible employees in the cadres of EA, SEA, AE and ADE of AIR &DD.
Though a court's verdict has to be implemented suo motu in case of all similarly situated employees without forcing every one of them to approach courts of law for the same relief, the Ministry of I&B has always been trifling with the judgments if it belonged to subordinate engineering employees. On the contrary, the Ministry has been implementing the CAT judgments in individual cases to all of the officers and to all the cadres if it belonged to Class A officers, without filing any review application or challenging in higher courts. For extension of the benefits of the order dated 07.09.2009 of CAT, Patna Bench in ACP case, plethora of court cases had to be filed by the eligible employees and the Ministry of I&B has not implemented the orders of the Tribunal even after the time limit given by the Tribunal for implementation was over.
Ministry of I&B filed one more Writ Petition CWJC No. 1869/2015 before Patna High Court for rescinding of CAT, Patna's judgment dated 07.09.2009 in OA No. 514/2002 and withdrawal of its earlier order dated 25.08.2010 in CWJC No 6451/2010, but the High Court dismissed the Writ Petition having no merit. Hon'ble Patna High Court has held the judgment dated 07.09.2009 in OA No. 514/2002 fully valid in one another Writ Petition CWJC No. 2797/2014 filed by Sh. N. K. srivastava & 5 others vide judgment dated 29.06.2015. The Ministry of I&B has so far implemented in case of following 26 engineering employees :
(a). 09 applicants (out of 12 applicants) in OA No. 514/2002 titled Akashvani & Doordarshan Diploma Engineers Association v/s UOI & Ors. decided by
CAT, Patna Bench.
(b). 01 applicant in OA No. 477/2011 titled Praveen Kumar v/s UOI & Ors. decided by CAT, New Delhi.
(c). 16 applicants (out of 23 applicants) in Doordarshan Engineering Employees Welfare Association & Ors v/s UOI & Ors. decided by CAT, New Delhi.
It may also be noted that ACP benefits has been allowed to Shri B. K. Roy, SEA, AIR, CBS, Patna in correct way counting 12 years of service from the date of his initial appointment in service. The Patna Bench of CAT has further directed the Govt. vide order dated 31.01.2014 in OA No. 350/2013 to grant the benefits of the ACP Scheme to 3 petitioners also ( Sh. H.K.Mishra, Sh. Sudhanshu Kumar and Sh. Manoranjan Kumar) by counting 12 years of service from the date of their initial appointment in service as has been allowed in case of Sh. B. K. Roy.
|
FUNDAMENTAL ORDERS OF DOP&T ON ACP SCHEME NOTIFIED ON 09.08.1999 |
||||
| A. |
FURTHER EXPLANATION: Grounds for the extension of benefits of the ACP scheme to EA, SEA & AE of AIR & DD. |
Click here | ||
| 10 | 04.10.2012 | DOP&T | ACP Scheme for the Central Government Civilian Employees- Clarification | Click here |
| 9. | 23.12.2008 | DOP&T | Convening of DPC of Group "B" officers for grant of ACP | Click here |
| 8. | 29.06.2004 | DOP&T | ACP Scheme for the Central Government Civilian Employees- Clarification | Click here |
| 7. | 12.09.2003 | DOP&T | ACP Scheme for the Central Government Civilian Employees- Clarification | Click here |
| 6. | 20.08.2001 | DOP&T | ACP Scheme - Clarification for deputationists | Click here |
| 5. |
18.07.2001 |
DOP&T |
Clarifications on ACP Scheme for Central Govt. Employees notified by GOI, DOP&T's Order No. 35034/1/97-Estt(D)(Vol.IV), dated 18.07.2001. |
Click here |
| 4. | 01.06.2001 |
DOP&T |
Grant of Fin. upgradations under ACPS to Gr D Civilian Govt. Employees- Clarification | Click here |
| 3. | 24.04.2000 |
DOP&T |
Implementation of ACP Scheme – Regarding | Click here |
| 2. |
10.02.2000 |
DOP&T |
Clarifications on ACP Scheme for Central Govt. Employees notified by GOI, DOP&T's Order No. 35034/1/97-Estt(D)(Vol.IV), dated 10.02.2000. |
|
| 1. |
09.08.1999 |
DOP&T |
ACP Scheme for Central Govt. Employees notified by GOI, DOP&T's Order No. 35034/1/97-Estt(D), dated 09.08.1999. |
Click here |
|
Sr. No. |
Judgments of various Courts for grant of ACP benefits |
To View, Click |
||
| 49. | 01.08.2019 |
CAT, Patna |
The OA No. 610/2014 filed by B.K.Roy & others for re-designation of EA/SEA/AE as per their Grade Pay of Rs 5400/Rs 6600 i.e.ADE, DDE is dismissed. | Click here |
| 48. | 01.08.2019 |
CAT, Patna |
OA No.702/2014 filed by B.K.Roy & 2 others before Patna CAT for grant of 1st ACP in the Scale of Rs 10000-15200 analogous to Asst. Surveyors/ Asst. Engineers of CCW of AIR & DD is dismissed . | Click here |
| 47. | 04.02.2019 |
Supreme Court |
Supreme Court judgment dtd 04.02.19 in CA No. 211/2019 filed by N.K.Srivastava of Patna |
Click here |
| 46. | 08.08.2018 |
CAT, Delhi |
Delhi Judgment dated 08.08.2018 in OA No. 305/2015 titled Neeraj Tirkey & 115 others in grant od ACP |
Click here |
| 45. | 13.07.2017 |
Delhi High Court |
Delhi High Court allows ACP/MACP to PSA in upgraded scales of MIB's OM dated 25.02.1999 |
Click here |
| 44. | 21.07.2016 |
CAT, Delhi |
Order dated 21.07.2016 of CAT, Delhi in CP No.555/2015 in OA No. 164/2014 of 07 applicants of DEEWA v/s UOI & Ors |
Click here |
| 43. | 13.07.2016 |
High Court Patna |
Click here | |
| 42. | 19.04.2016 |
CAT, Delhi |
Order dated 19.04.2016 of CAT, Delhi in CP No.443/2015 in OA No.4191/2013 of Anil Kumar Sharma & 39 Ors vs UOI & Ors. |
Click here |
| 41. | 17.03.2016 |
CAT, Delhi |
Order dated 17.03.2016 of CAT, Delhi in CP No.396 & 606 of 2014 in OA No.854/2014 of Y.P.Singh, CP No.673/2015 in OA No.2608/2015 of S.K.Singh & CP. No. 664/2015 in OA No. 4462/2013 of UADEE (Total three CPs) |
Click here |
| 40. | 10.03.2016 |
CAT, Delhi |
Order dated 10.03.2016 of CAT, Delhi in CP No.357/2015 in OA No. 2591/2013 of Vinod Kumar & 06 Ors v/s UOI & Ors |
Click here |
| 39. | 18.11.2015 |
CAT, Delhi |
Order dated 18.11.2015 of CAT, Delhi in CP No.508/2015 in OA No. 215/2015 of Sushil Kumar Agarwal & Ors v/s UOI & Ors |
Click here |
| 38. | 16.10.2015 |
CAT, Delhi |
Order dated 16.10.2015 of CAT, Delhi in CP No.68/2015 in OA No. 3580/2014 of Joginder.Singh & 15 Ors v/s UOI & Ors |
Click here |
| 37. | 21.07.2015 |
CAT, Delhi |
Order dated 21.07.2015 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 2608/2015 of S.K.Singh & 73 Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 74 applicants) |
Click here |
| 36. | 29.06.2015 |
High Court Patna |
Order dated 29.06.2015 of Patna High Court in Writ Petition No.CWJC No. 2797/2014 titled N.K.Srivastava & 5 Ors |
Click here |
| 35. | 21.05.2015 |
CAT, Delhi |
Order dated 21.05.2015 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 4462/2013 of UADEE & 92 Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 93 applicants) |
Click here |
| 34. | 12.05.2015 |
High Court Patna |
Order dated 12.05.2015 of Patna High Court in Writ Petition No. CWJC No.1869/2015 in OA No. 514/2002 |
Click here |
| 33. | 06.05.2015 |
CAT, Delhi |
Order dated 06.05.2015 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 164/2014 of DEEWA & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 8 applicants) |
Click here |
| 32. | 28.01.2015 |
CAT, Delhi |
Order dated 28.01.2015 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 4191/2013 of Anil Kr Sharma & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 40 applicants) |
Click here |
| 31. | 28.01.2015 |
CAT, Delhi |
Order dated 28.01.2015 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 2591/2013 of Vinod Kr & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 7 applicants) |
Click here |
| 30. | 19.01.2015 |
CAT, Delhi |
Order dated 19.01.2015 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 215/2015 of S.K.Agrawal & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 154 applicants) |
Click here |
| 29. | 03.12.2014 |
CAT, Delhi |
Order dated 03.12.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 4280/2014 of A.M.Sharma & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 43 applicants) |
Click here |
| 28. | 01.12.2014 |
CAT, Delhi |
Order dated 01.12.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 4249/2014 of ARTEE & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 04 applicants) |
Click here |
| 27. | 14.11.2014 |
CAT, Delhi |
Order dated 14.11.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 4028/2014 of A.K.Bhatnagar & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 99 applicants) |
Click here |
| 26. | 15.10.2014 |
CAT, Delhi |
Order dated 15.10.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No.3675/2014 of MRC Reddy & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 23 applicants) |
Click here |
| 25. | 09.10.2014 |
CAT, Delhi |
Order dated 09.10.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 3580/2014 of Joginder Singh & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 16 applicants) |
Click here |
| 24. | 15.05.2014 |
CAT, Delhi |
Order dated 15.05.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 854/2014 of Y. P. Singh & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 177 applicants) |
Click here |
| 23 | 05.04.2014 |
HC, Delhi |
Order dated 05.04.2014 of Delhi High Court in WP No. 4618/2013 of N.Manjunath & Ors v/s UOI & Ors on grant of 2nd ACP to Sound Recordist in the Pay Scale of Rs 8000-13500. |
Click here |
| 22. | 03.03.2014 |
CAT, Delhi |
Order dated 03.03.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 1147/2013 of Thomas Mathew & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 09 applicants) |
Click here |
| 21. | 31.01.2014 |
CAT, Patna |
Order dated 31.01.2014 of CAT, Patna in OA No. 350/2013 of H.K.Mishra & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 03 applicants) |
Click here |
| 20. | 24.12.2013 |
CAT,Delhi |
Order dated 24.12.2013 of Delhi CAT in OA No. 4520/2013 of Pradeep Galhotra vs UOI (Total 61 applicants) |
Click here |
| 19. | 20.12.2013 |
CAT,Delhi |
Order dated 20.12.2013 of Delhi CAT in OA No. 4439/2013 of Pradeep Gupta vs UOI (Total 35 applicants) |
Click here |
| 18. | 31.10.2013 |
CAT,Delhi |
Order dated 31.10.2013 of Delhi CAT in OA No. 3106/2013 of Manoj Kumar Gupta vs UOI (Total 26 applicants) |
Click here |
| 17. | 23.10.2013 |
High Court Patna |
Order dated 23.10.2013 of Patna High Court in Review Petition No. 141/2012 in OA No. 514/2002 |
Click here |
|
16. |
13.03.2013 |
CAT,Delhi |
Order dated 13.03.2013 of the Delhi CAT in OA No. 879/2013 of S.K.Mishra & ors vs UOI vs UOI (Total 07 applicants) |
Click here |
|
15. |
04.03.2013 |
CAT,Delhi |
Order dated 04.03.2013 of the Delhi CAT in OA No. 757/2013 of Umesh Chandra & 10 ors vs UOI vs UOI (Total 11 applicants) |
Click here |
|
14. |
01.03.2013 |
CAT,Delhi |
Order dated 01.03.2013 of the Delhi CAT in CP No. 710/2011 in OA No. 597/2011 of DEEWA vs UOI |
Click here |
|
13. |
09.10.2012 |
CAT,Delhi |
Order dated 09.10.2012 of the Delhi CAT in OA No. 3400/2012 of Vinod Kumar & Others vs UOI (Total 07 applicants) |
Click here |
|
12. |
24.05.2011 |
CAT,Delhi |
Order dated 24.05.2011 of the Delhi CAT in OA No. 597/2011 of DEEWA vs UOI (Total 23 applicants) |
Click here |
|
11. |
23.05.2012 |
CAT,Patna |
Order dated 23.05.2012 of the Patna CAT in Contempt Petition CCPA No.22/2011 in OA No. 514/2002 |
Click here |
| 10. | 02.03.2012 |
CAT,Patna |
Interim order dated 02.03.2012 of the Patna CAT in Contempt Petition CCPA No.22/2011 in OA No. 514/2002 |
Click here |
|
9. |
01.02.2012 |
CAT,Delhi |
Order dated 01.02.2011 of the Delhi CAT in OA No. 477/2011 of Praveen Kumar vs UOI |
Click here |
|
8. |
17.01.2012 |
DGAIR |
Order dated 17.01.2012 of DGAIR on grant of ACP benefits to 08 petitioners of Patna |
Click here |
|
7. |
03.01.2012 |
MIB |
Minutes of 2nd Screening Committee of MIB dated 03.01.2012 vide No. 503/17/2011-BA(E) granting ACP to 08 petitioners of Patna |
Click here |
| 6. | 08.12.2011 |
CAT,Patna |
Interim order dated 08.12.2011 of the Patna CAT in Contempt Petition CCPA No.22/2011 in OA No. 514/2002 |
Click here |
|
5. |
04.11.2011 |
MIB |
Order dated 04.11.2011 of Ministry of I&B declaring the petitioners of Patna as ineligible for ACP benefits on findings of Screening Committee |
Click here |
|
4. |
29.06.2011 |
MIB |
Order dated 29.06.2011 of Ministry of I&B along with comments of DOP&T, Ministry of Finance & Ministry of Law on grant of ACP |
Click here |
|
3. |
10.01.2011 |
Supreme Court |
Order dated 10.01.2011 of the Supreme Court in CC No.20212/2010 |
Click here |
|
2. |
25.08.2010 |
High Court Patna |
Order dated 25.08.2010 of the Patna High Court in CWJC 6451/2010 |
Click here |
|
1. |
07.09.2009 |
CAT,Patna |
Order dated 07.09.2009 of CAT, Patna bench in OA No.514/2002 titled B.K.Roy & 11 others |
Click here |
|
Sr. No. |
Date |
Autrhority |
Orders issued by Ministry of I&B, Prasar Bharati & DG:AIR on implementation of Courts'orders for grant of ACP benefits to EA/SEA/AE |
To View, Click |
| 43. | 15.05.2019 |
DG:AIR |
Speaking order dated 13.05.2017 of DGAIR withdrawing ACP benefit to B.K.Roy, H.K.Mishra & Sudhanshu Kumar is withdrwan on interim order of CAT Patna in OA No.283/2018 |
Click here |
| 42. | 17.12.2015 |
DG:AIR |
Speaking order dated 17.12.2015 of DGAIR in N.K.Srivastava's WP No.2797/2014 |
Click here |
| 41. | 13.10.2015 |
DG:AIR |
Speaking order dated 13.10.2015 of DGAIR saying that applicants herein are not similarly placed. |
Click here |
| 40. |
12.10.2015 |
DGAIR |
Minutes of Screening Committee of DGAIR dated 12.10.2015 denying ACP benefits to all |
Click here |
| 39. | 22.09.2015 |
DG:AIR |
Collection of biodata of applicants in OA No. 757/2013 titled Umesh Chandra & 10 others |
Click here |
| 38. | 18.09.2015 |
DG:AIR |
Collection of biodata of applicants in 5 OAs including Y.P.Singh's and S.K.Agarwal's |
Click here |
| 37. |
18.09.2015 |
DGAIR |
Pay Fixation order dated 20.08.2013 in case of H.K.Mishra etc for.counting 12 years of service from date of entry in service in OA No. 350/2013 |
Click here |
| 36. | 07.08.2015 |
DGAIR |
DGAIR's letter to zonal ADG for collection of biodata of EA/SEA/SEA |
Click here |
| 35. | 15.07.2015 |
DGAIR |
DGAIR's letter to zonal ADG for collection of biodata of EA/SEA/SEA |
Click here |
| 34. | 17.06.2015 |
MIB |
MIB delegates power of holding meeting of Screening Committee to DGAIR in ACP cases |
Click here |
| 33. | 16.06.2015 |
PB |
Member(P)'s DO letter to Chairman(PB), Secretary(MIB), Secretary(Expenditure), Min of Finance |
Click here |
| 32. | 15.06.2015 |
DGAIR |
DGAIR's letter to zonal ADG for collection of biodata of EA/SEA/SEA- corrigendum |
Click here |
| 31. | 05.06.2015 |
DGAIR |
DGAIR's letter to zonal ADG for collection of biodata of EA/SEA/SEA |
Click here |
| 30. | 07.04.2015 |
DGAIR |
Speaking Order given by DGAIR in OA No. 1155/2013 of K.Kannan (CAT, Chennai Bench) |
Click here |
|
29. |
25.02.2015 |
DGAIR |
DGAIR gives Speaking order to H.K.Mishra etc vide letter dtd 25.02.15 in OA No. 350/2013 |
Click here |
| 28. | 06.02.2015 |
DGAIR |
Speaking Order given by DGAIR in OA No. 215/2015 of S. K. Agarwal & 153 others |
Click here |
| 27. | 30.01.2015 |
DGAIR |
Speaking Order given by DGAIR in OA No. 854/2014 of Y.P.Singh & 176 others |
Click here |
| 26. | 21.01.2015 |
MIB |
MIB delegates power of holding meeting of Screening Committee to DGAIR in ACP cases |
Click here |
| 25. | 27.10.2014 |
MIB |
MIB's letter to DGAIR for filing of Review Petition before Patna High Court and also prepare proposal in 09 OAs |
Click here |
| 24. | 17.10.2014 |
PB(BCI) |
Proposal of PB to Sec(I&B) to grant ACP benefits to all eligible EA/SEA/AE |
Click here |
| 23. | 15.09.2014 |
DGAIR |
DGAIR's letter to zonal ADG for collection of biodata of EA/SEA/SEA |
Click here |
| 22. | 30.06.2014 |
MIB |
MIB's letter to DGAIR for consideration of cases of 177 applicants in OA No. 854/2014 of Y. P. Singh & Others |
Click here |
| 21. | 16.04.2014 |
MIB |
MIB's letter to DGAIR for taking 12 months time from CAT Delhi to file Writ in Patna high Court |
Click here |
| 20. | 03.04.2014 |
DGAIR |
DGAIR's DO letter to MIB on grant of ACP- corrigendum |
Click here |
| 19. | 31.03.2014 |
PB(BCI) |
PB's letter to DGAIR on grant of ACP- corrigendum |
Click here |
| 18. | 24.03.2014 |
DGAIR |
DGAIR's DO letter to MIB on grant of ACP |
Click here |
| 17. | 27.01.2014 |
MIB |
MIB delegates power of holding meeting of Screening Committee to DGAIR in 08 OAs including OA No. 4191/2013 |
Click here |
|
16. |
29.08.2013 |
RC,Todapur |
Pay Fixation order dated 29.08.2013 in case of Shri Manish Kumar Jain, SEA of DEEWA |
Click here |
| 15. |
20.08.2013 |
AIR,CBS,Patna |
Pay Fixation order dated 20.08.2013 in case of Shri B.K.Roy, SEA of AIR,Patna.counting 12 years of service from date of entry in service |
Click here |
|
14. |
10.07.2013 |
DDK,Patna |
Pay Fixation order dated 10.07.2013 in case of Shri H.K.Mishra, SEA of DDK,Patna. |
Click here |
|
13. |
04.03.2013 |
PB(BCI) |
Letter dtd 04.03.2013 to DGAIR on implementation of ACP to applicants of OA 514/2012 |
Click here |
|
12. |
04.03.2013 |
DGAIR |
Pay Fixation order dated 04.03.2013 in case of Shri B.K.Roy, SEA of AIR,Patna.counting 12 years of service from date of entry in service |
Click here |
| 11. | 12.02.2013 |
MIB |
Pay Fixation order dated 12.02.2013 in case of Shri B.K.Roy, SEA of AIR,Patna.counting 12 years of service from date of entry in service |
Click here |
|
10. |
14.01.2013 |
MIB |
Minutes of Screening Committee of MIB dated 14.01.2013 vide No. 503/17/2011-BA(E) granting ACP to 16 petitioners of DEEWA out of 23 |
Click here |
|
9. |
15.06.2012 |
MIB |
Minutes of Screening Committee of MIB dated 15.06.2012 to grant ACP to Praveen Kumar |
Click here |
|
8. |
17.01.2012 |
DGAIR |
Order dated 17.01.2012 of DGAIR on grant of ACP benefits to 08 petitioners of Patna out of 12 |
Click here |
|
7. |
03.01.2012 |
MIB |
Minutes of 2nd Screening Committee of MIB dated 03.01.2012 vide No. 503/17/2011-BA(E) granting ACP to 08 petitioners of Patna |
Click here |
|
6. |
04.11.2011 |
MIB |
Order dated 04.11.2011 of Ministry of I&B declaring the petitioners of Patna as ineligible for ACP benefits on findings of Screening Committee |
Click here |
|
5. |
24.10.2011 |
MIB |
Minutes of 1st Screening Committee of MIB dated 24.10.2011 vide No. 503/07/2011-BA(E) to grant ACP to the petitioners of Patna |
Click here |
|
4. |
05.07.2011 |
DGAIR |
Order dated 05.07.2011 of DGAIR on grant of ACP benefits to petitioners of Patna |
Click here |
|
3. |
29.06.2011 |
MIB |
Order dated 29.06.2011 of Ministry of I&B along with comments of DOP&T, Ministry of Finance & Ministry of Law on grant of ACP |
Click here |
| 2. | 23.12.2008 |
MOF,DOE |
Screening Committee for grant of ACP to Gr.B officers- Clarification |
Click here |
|
1. |
15.07.2004 |
DGAIR |
Order dated 15.07.2004 of DGAIR on denial of ACP benefits to EA/SEA/AE saying Clarification No. 35 is not applicable |
Click here |