Union of Akashvani & Doordarshan (Prasar Bharati) Engineering Employees (UADEE)
(Registered under Trade Union Act, 1926; Regn.No. 5135)
Head
Quarter : C-4 D/ 81 B, Janakpuri, New Delhi-110
058
visit our website: http://www.uadee.org
| IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS OF COURTS IN SERVICE MATTERS | ||||
|
Sr. No. |
COURTS |
DATE OF JUDGMENTS |
CASES |
To View, Click |
|
A
|
Revision of Pay Scale of Sound Recordists of DD leading to revision of pay scales of EA OF AIR & DOORDARSHAN |
|||
|
01 |
SCI | 26.08.1988 | Judgment of Supreme Court in WP No.974/1978, 1239/1979 & 1756/1986 titled Y.K.Mehta v/s UOI | Click here |
|
02 |
SCI | 12.04.1990 | Judgment of Supreme Court in WP No.240/1989 titled DD CWA v/s UOI | Click here |
|
B
|
Revision of Pay Scale of EA OF AIR & DD consequent upon revision of pay scales of Sound Recordists of DD | |||
|
01 |
Background for Revision of Pay scales of Engineering Assistants of AIR & Doordarshan | Click here | ||
|
02 |
CAT,Madras |
29.06.1990 |
Judgment of CAT, Madras Bench in OA No.654/1989 titled A. Rajasekaran v/s MIB & DGDD. | Click here |
|
03 |
SCI | 07.01.1991 | SLP filed by MIB before SCI against judgment dated 29.06.1990 of CAT, Madras Bench is dismissed on merits | Click here |
|
04 |
CAT,Madras | 10.06.1992 | Judgment of CAT, Madras Bench rescinding its judgment dated 29.06.1990 in Review Petition No.4 of OA No. 654 filed by UOI | Click here |
|
05 |
SCI | 25.11.1994 | Judgment of SCI upholding judgment dated 29.06.1990 of CAT, Madras Bench and thus giving finality to revision of scale of EA | Click here |
|
C
|
Revision of Pay Scale of SEA OF AIR & DOORDARSHAN consequent upon revision of pay scales of EA | |||
|
01 |
Background for Revision of Pay scales of Sr. Engineering Assistants of AIR & Doordarshan | Click here | ||
|
02 |
CAT,Bangalore | 16.02.2000 | Judgment of CAT, Bangalore Bench in OA No.654/1989 titled A. Rajasekaran v/s MIB & DGDD. | Click here |
|
03 |
HC,Karnataka | 14.02.2001 | Judgment of Karnataka High Court in Writ Petitions No. judgment dated 29.06.1990 in Review Petition No.4 of OA No. 654 filed by UOI | Click here |
|
04 |
SCI | 17.12.2001 | Judgment of SCI upholding judgment dated 29.06.1990 of CAT, Madras Bench and thus giving finality to revision of scale of EA | Click here |
|
D
|
RECRUITMENT RULES - 1982 OF ASSISTANT ENGINEERS OF AIR & DOORDARSHAN |
|||
|
01 |
CAT, Delhi | 31.12.1986 | Assistant Engineer Recruitment Rules, 1982 is discriminatory & violative of Art.14 &16 of Constitution of India-Courts' Judgments | Click here |
|
02 |
SCI | 04.05.1987 | Assistant Engineer Recruitment Rules, 1982 is discriminatory & violative of Art.14 &16 of Constitution of India-Courts' Judgments | Click here |
|
03 |
SCI | 10.08.1987 | Assistant Engineer Recruitment Rules, 1982 is discriminatory & violative of Art.14 &16 of Constitution of India-Courts' Judgments | Click here |
|
E
|
RECRUITMENT RULES - 1985 OF ASSISTANT ENGINEERS OF AIR & DOORDARSHAN |
|||
|
01 |
CAT, Delhi | 03.05.1991 | Assistant Engineer Recruitment Rules, 1985 is lawful and valid-Courts' Judgments | Click here |
|
02 |
SCI | 09.09.1997 | Assistant Engineer Recruitment Rules, 1985 is lawful and valid-Courts' Judgments | Click here |
|
F
|
JUDGMENTS AGAINST/FOR IB(E)S AMENDMENT RULES, 1989 | |||
|
01 |
Background - Degree holders cannot have preferential treatment in promotions at JTS level | Click here | ||
|
02 |
CAT,Lucknow | 28.10.2002 | Judgment of CAT, Lucknow Bench in OA No.218/1995 titled Romesh Chander Nadir & ors v/s UOI | Click here |
|
03 |
HC,Lucknow | 24.10.2003 | Judgment of High Court, Lucknow Bench in WP No.251/2003 titled UOI & ors v/s Romesh Chander Nadir & ors | Click here |
|
04 |
SCI | 05.12.2003 | Judgment of Supreme Court in SLP No.21643/2003 titled Romesh Chander Nadir & ors v/s UOI | Click here |
|
05 |
CAT,Cuttack | 22.03.2004 | Judgment of CAT, Cuttack Bench in OA No.538/1999 titled U.K.Sahoo & ors v/s UOI | Click here |
|
G
|
Revision of Pay Scale of Lighting Assistants of DD at par with Assistant Cameraman of FILMS IVISION | |||
|
01 |
Background - Brief history of parity of pay scale between Lighting Assistants of DD and Assistant Cameraman of Film Division | Click here | ||
|
02 |
CAT, Delhi | 15.05.2007 | Judgment of CAT,New Dehi in Sanjeev Kumar's OA No.2386/2005, dated 15.05.2007 | Click here |
|
03 |
HC, Delhi | 15.12.2010 | Judgment of Delhi High Court in Govt's Writ Petition (C) No.6544/2007, dated 15.12.2010 | Click here |
|
04 |
CAT, Delhi | 18.05.2012 | Judgment of CAT,New Dehi in P. Satyanarayana Rao's OA No.1700/2012, dated 18.05.2012 | Click here |
|
H
|
Revision of Pay Scale of Tech. & Sr.Tech. OF AIR & DD consequent upon revision of pay scales of Lighting Assistants OF DD | |||
|
01 |
Background - Brief history of revision of pay scale of Tech at par with Lighting Assistants of DD | Click here | ||
|
02 |
CAT, Delhi | 14.12.1999 | Judgment of CAT, New Delhi in OA No.164/1996, dated 14.12.1999 in ARTEE's case | NA |
|
03 |
HC, Delhi | 08.07.2011 | Judgment of Delhi High Court in CWP No.3787/2000, dated 08.07.2011 in ARTEE's case | Click here |
|
04 |
SCI | 02.09.2013 | Judgment of Sup.Court in RP(Civil) No.2276/2012 in SLP(C) No.14381/2012,dated 02.09.2013 in ARTEE's case | Click here |
|
05 |
CAT,Chennai | 10.07.2008 | Judgment of CAT,Chennai Bench in OA No.390/2006, dated 10.07.2008 in ADTEA's case | Click here |
|
06 |
HC,Chennai | 24.11.2010 | Judgment of Chennai High Court in WP(C) No.27155/2009, dated 24.11.2010 in ADTEA's case | Click here |
|
07 |
SCI | 10.01.2013 | Judgment of Supreme Court in SLP(C) No.33048/2011, dated 10.01.2013 in ADTEA's case | Click here |
|
08 |
CAT, Delhi | 15.12.2014 | Judgment of CAT, New Delhi in OA No.4424/2014 of ARTEE for pay scale of 5000-8000 to Tech at par with LA | Click here |
|
09 |
CAT, Delhi | 01.04.2015 | Judgment of CAT, New Delhi in OA No.1861/2014 of Ashok Kr Yadav for pay scale of 5000-8000 to Tech at par with LA | Click here |
|
10 |
CAT, Delhi | 15.02.2016 | Judgment of CAT, New Delhi in RA148/2015 in OA No.1861/2014 of Ashok Kr Yadav for PS of 5000-8000 to Tech at par with LA | Click here |
|
I
|
Grant of ACP AS RECOMMENDED BY 5TH CPC |
|||
|
Background - Reasons for admissibility and litigation with the Govt |
Click here | |||
|
01 |
CAT,Patna |
07.09.2009 |
Order dated 07.09.2009 of CAT, Patna bench in OA No.514/2002 titled B.K.Roy & 11 others |
Click here |
|
02 |
HC, Patna |
25.08.2010 |
Order dated 25.08.2010 of the Patna High Court in CWJC 6451/2010 |
Click here |
|
03 |
SCI |
10.01.2011 |
Order dated 10.01.2011 of the Supreme Court in CC No.20212/2010 |
Click here |
|
04 |
MIB |
29.06.2011 |
Order dated 29.06.2011 of Ministry of I&B along with comments of DOP&T, Ministry of Finance & Ministry of Law on grant of ACP |
Click here |
|
05 |
MIB |
04.11.2011 |
Order dated 04.11.2011 of Ministry of I&B declaring the petitioners of Patna as ineligible for ACP benefits on findings of Screening Committee |
Click here |
|
06 |
CAT,Patna |
08.12.2011 |
Interim order dated 08.12.2011 of the Patna CAT in Contempt Petition CCPA No.22/2011 in OA No. 514/2002 |
Click here |
|
07 |
MIB |
03.01.2012 |
Minutes of 2nd Screening Committee of MIB dated 03.01.2012 vide No. 503/17/2011-BA(E) granting ACP to 08 petitioners of Patna |
Click here |
|
08 |
DGAIR |
17.01.2012 |
Order dated 17.01.2012 of DGAIR on grant of ACP benefits to 08 petitioners of Patna |
Click here |
|
09 |
CAT,Delhi |
01.02.2012 |
Order dated 01.02.2011 of the Delhi CAT in OA No. 477/2011 of Praveen Kumar vs UOI |
Click here |
|
10 |
CAT,Patna |
02.03.2012 |
Interim order dated 02.03.2012 of the Patna CAT in Contempt Petition CCPA No.22/2011 in OA No. 514/2002 |
Click here |
|
11 |
CAT,Patna |
23.05.2012 |
Order dated 23.05.2012 of the Patna CAT in Contempt Petition CCPA No.22/2011 in OA No. 514/2002 |
Click here |
|
12 |
CAT,Delhi |
24.05.2011 |
Order dated 24.05.2011 of the Delhi CAT in OA No. 597/2011 of DEEWA vs UOI (Total 23 applicants) |
Click here |
|
13 |
CAT,Delhi |
09.10.2012 |
Order dated 09.10.2012 of the Delhi CAT in OA No. 3400/2012 of Vinod Kumar & Others vs UOI (Total 07 applicants) |
Click here |
|
14 |
CAT,Delhi |
01.03.2013 |
Order dated 01.03.2013 of the Delhi CAT in CP No. 710/2011 in OA No. 597/2011 of DEEWA vs UOI |
Click here |
|
15 |
CAT,Delhi |
04.03.2013 |
Order dated 04.03.2013 of the Delhi CAT in OA No. 757/2013 of Umesh Chandra & 10 ors vs UOI vs UOI (Total 11 applicants) |
Click here |
|
16 |
CAT,Delhi |
13.03.2013 |
Order dated 13.03.2013 of the Delhi CAT in OA No. 879/2013 of S.K.Mishra & ors vs UOI vs UOI (Total 07 applicants) |
Click here |
|
17 |
HC Patna |
23.10.2013 |
Order dated 23.10.2013 of Patna High Court in Review Petition No. 141/2012 in OA No. 514/2002 |
Click here |
|
18 |
CAT,Delhi |
31.10.2013 |
Order dated 31.10.2013 of Delhi CAT in OA No. 3106/2013 of Manoj Kumar Gupta vs UOI (Total 26 applicants) |
Click here |
|
19 |
CAT,Delhi |
20.12.2013 |
Order dated 20.12.2013 of Delhi CAT in OA No. 4439/2013 of Pradeep Gupta vs UOI (Total 35 applicants) |
Click here |
|
20 |
CAT,Delhi |
24.12.2013 |
Order dated 24.12.2013 of Delhi CAT in OA No. 4520/2013 of Pradeep Galhotra vs UOI (Total 61 applicants) |
Click here |
|
21 |
CAT, Patna |
31.01.2014 |
Order dated 31.01.2014 of CAT, Patna in OA No. 350/2013 of H.K.Mishra & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 03 applicants) |
Click here |
|
22 |
CAT, Delhi |
03.03.2014 |
Order dated 03.03.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 1147/2013 of Thomas Mathew & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 09 applicants) |
Click here |
|
23 |
Delhi HC | 05.04.2014 |
Order dated 05.04.2014 of Delhi HC in WP No. 4618/2013 of N.Manjunath & Ors v/s UOI & Ors on grant of 2nd ACP to Sound Recordist in the Pay Scale of Rs 8000-13500. |
Click here |
|
24 |
CAT, Delhi | 15.05.2014 |
Order dated 15.05.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 854/2014 of Y. P. Singh & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 177 applicants) |
Click here |
|
25 |
CAT, Delhi | 09.10.2014 |
Order dated 09.10.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 3580/2014 of Joginder Singh & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 16 applicants) |
Click here |
|
26 |
CAT, Delhi | 15.10.2014 |
Order dated 15.10.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No.3675/2014 of MRC Reddy & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 23 applicants) |
Click here |
|
27 |
CAT, Delhi | 14.11.2014 |
Order dated 14.11.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 4028/2014 of A.K.Bhatnagar & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 99 applicants) |
Click here |
|
28 |
CAT, Delhi | 01.12.2014 |
Order dated 01.12.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 4249/2014 of ARTEE & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 04 applicants) |
Click here |
|
29 |
CAT, Delhi | 03.12.2014 |
Order dated 03.12.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 4280/2014 of A.M.Sharma & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 43 applicants) |
Click here |
|
30 |
CAT, Delhi | 19.01.2015 |
Order dated 19.01.2015 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 215/2015 of S.K.Agrawal & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 154 applicants) |
Click here |
|
31 |
CAT, Delhi | 28.01.2015 |
Order dated 28.01.2015 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 2591/2013 of Vinod Kr & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 7 applicants) |
Click here |
|
32 |
CAT, Delhi | 28.01.2015 |
Order dated 28.01.2015 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 4191/2013 of Anil Kr Sharma & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 40 applicants) |
Click here |
|
33 |
CAT, Delhi |
06.05.2015 |
Order dated 06.05.2015 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 164/2014 of DEEWA & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 8 applicants) |
Click here |
|
34 |
Patna HC |
12.05.2015 |
Order dated 12.05.2015 of Patna High Court in Writ Petition No. CWJC No.1869/2015 in OA No. 514/2002 |
Click here |
|
35 |
CAT, Delhi | 21.05.2015 |
Order dated 21.05.2015 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 4462/2013 of UADEE & 92 Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 93 applicants) |
Click here |
|
36 |
Patna HC |
29.06.2015 |
Order dated 29.06.2015 of Patna High Court in Writ Petition No.CWJC No. 2797/2014 titled N.K.Srivastava & 5 Ors |
Click here |
|
37 |
CAT, Delhi | 21.07.2015 |
Order dated 21.07.2015 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 2608/2015 of S.K.Singh & 73 Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 74 applicants) |
Click here |
|
38 |
CAT, Delhi | 16.10.2015 |
Order dated 16.10.2015 of CAT, Delhi in CP No.68/2015 in OA No. 3580/2014 of Joginder.Singh & 15 Ors v/s UOI & Ors |
Click here |
|
39 |
CAT, Delhi | 18.11.2015 |
Order dated 18.11.2015 of CAT, Delhi in CP No.508/2015 in OA No. 215/2015 of Sushil Kumar Agarwal & Ors v/s UOI & Ors |
Click here |
|
40 |
CAT, Delhi | 10.03.2016 |
Order dated 10.03.2016 of CAT, Delhi in CP No.357/2015 in OA No. 2591/2013 of Vinod Kumar & 06 Ors v/s UOI & Ors |
Click here |
|
41 |
CAT, Delhi | 17.03.2016 |
Order dated 17.03.2016 of CAT, Delhi in CP No.396 & 606 of 2014 in OA No.854/2014 of Y.P.Singh, CP No.673/2015 in OA No.2608/2015 of S.K.Singh & CP. No. 664/2015 in OA No. 4462/2013 of UADEE (Total three CPs) |
Click here |
|
42 |
CAT, Delhi |
19.04.2016 |
Order dated 19.04.2016 of CAT, Delhi in CP No.443/2015 in OA No.4191/2013 of Anil Kumar Sharma & 39 Ors vs UOI & Ors. |
|
|
43 |
HC, Patna |
13.07.2016 |
Click here | |
|
44 |
CAT, Delhi |
21.07.2016 |
Order dated 21.07.2016 of CAT, Delhi in CP No.555/2015 in OA No. 164/2014 of 07 applicants of DEEWA v/s UOI & Ors |
Click here |
|
45 |
Delhi HC |
13.07.2017 |
Delhi High Court allows ACP/MACP to PSA in upgraded scales of MIB's OM dated 25.02.1999 |
Click here |
|
46 |
CAT, Delhi |
08.08.2018 |
Delhi Judgment dated 08.08.2018 in OA No. 305/2015 titled Neeraj Tirkey & 115 others in grant od ACP |
Click here |
|
J
|
Grant of MACP AS RECOMMENDED BY 6TH & 7TH CPC |
|||
|
01 |
High Court | 19.10.2011 | Judgment of Chandigarh HC in CWP No.19387/2011 to give MACP in Promotional hierarchy - UOI vs Raj Pal | Click here |
|
02 |
CAT, Delhi | 26.11.2012 | Order of CAT in OA No.904/2012 to give MACP to Defence Staff in Promotional hierarchy | Click here |
|
03 |
SCI | 15.04.2013 | Judgment of Supreme Court in CC No.7467/2013 to give MACP in Promotional hierarchy - UOI vs Raj Pal | Click here |
|
04 |
CAT, Delhi | 12.03.2014 | Order of CAT in OA No.864/2014 to give MACP to NCERT in Promotional hierarchy | Click here |
|
05 |
CAT, Delhi | 21.03.2014 | Order of CAT in OA No.988/2014 to give MACP to CCW, AIR & DD, in Promotional hierarchy | |
|
06 |
Madras HC | 04.02.2015 | Judgment in WP No. 30629 of 2014: MACP to be granted ignoring promotion by LDCE- D. Sivakumar case | |
|
07 |
SCI | 16.08.2016 | Judgment in SLP(C) No. 4848 of 2016: MACP to be granted ignoring promotion by LDCE- D. Sivakumar case | |
|
08 |
High Court |
06.06.2017 / 20.12.17 |
Judgment in WP(C) No.9357/2017 : NFU in GP-5400 after 4 yrs service in GP-4800 in not countable in MACP - Hari Ram & others vs Registrar General of Delhi High Court | Click here |
|
09 |
SCI | 08.12.2017 | Judgment in CA Diary No. 3744 of 2016: MACP is admissible wef 01.01.2006 to Defence staff - UOI vs Balbir Singh Turn | |
|
10 |
MoD | 25.07.2018 | Order No.No.14\(1)/99-D(AG): General order of implementation for all employees of MoD | |
|
11 |
Bombay HC | 15.10.2018 | Judgment in WP(C) No.1763 of 2013: MACP is admissible wef 01.01.2006 - Case of M.P.Joseph | |
|
K
|
Grant of GRADE PAY OF Rs 5400 in PB-2 AFTER 4 YRS OF SERVICE IN GP-4800 AS PER 6TH CPC |
|||
|
01 |
HC |
13.06.2010 |
Judgment of Madras High Court in WP(C) No. 13225/2010 in case of Central Excise Inspectors | |
|
02 |
CAT |
06.08.2010 |
Judgment of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 2662/2009 of R.K.Jain & 3 Others | |
|
03 |
CAT |
24.11.2010 |
Corrected Judgment of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 2662/2009 of R.K.Jain & 3 Others | |
|
04 |
CAT |
17.04.2014 |
Judgment of CAT in RA No.12/2012 in OA No.2662/2009 |
|
|
05 |
CAT |
05.11.2014 |
Judgment of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 3048/12 of B.P.Dhaman & 1 Other | |
|
06 |
CAT |
23.04.2015 |
Judgment of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 1515/2015 of Neeraj Choudhary & 14 Others | |
|
07 |
CAT |
05.05.2015 |
Judgment of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 1667/2015 of S.K.Chaudhary & 46 Others | |
|
08 |
CAT |
08.05.2015 |
Judgment of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 1738/2015 of T.Purushan & 17 Others | |
|
09 |
CAT |
12.08.2015 |
Judgment of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 2949/2015 of Tribhuwan Pati & 34 Others | |
|
10 |
CAT |
14.08.2015 |
Judgment of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 3030/2015 of O.P.Rajpurohit & 22 Others | |
|
11 |
CAT |
08.12.2016 |
Judgment of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 3541/2016
filed by ARTEE
|
|